6 Ways to Lose at Negotiating a House Price

Andi • September 3, 2021

Real estate negotiation tips so you can buy your dream home — and not overpay.

Image: Hero Images/Getty

You’ve looked at enough houses to fill an entire season of  House Hunters  and finally picked one to buy. Now you’re  ready to make an offer .

Your agent can help guide you through this nail-biting phase of negotiating a house price, but ultimately, you call the shots. Here’s how to negotiate like a boss.

Fail #1: Thinking House Price is All That Matters

That house with a price point $15k below your budget? It may seem like a deal — until you add on the costs of maintenance and replacing the aging appliances.

Planning on repainting, remodeling, or landscaping, too? Suddenly the price looks a whole lot higher.

When developing your offer, calculate in the costs that will go above and beyond a mortgage payment. Then you can  negotiate with an eye on the total cost of owning the house , not just the sticker price.

On the flip side, the price may not be all that matters to the seller, either.

She may have to start a job on the other side of the country in a month and value a quick closing. Or she may be looking to rent from you for a bit after the sale until her next home is ready. Sometimes being accommodating is negotiation gold.

Fail #2: Refusing to Back Down on Small Repairs

Before you draw a line in the negotiation sand over, say, a deck with some rotten boards, ask yourself if it’s worth losing the house over a repair that would cost less than a thousand dollars.

Say the house price is $250,000, which makes that deck repair less than half of one percent of the cost of the house. There’s a lot of emotional energy at this point in the process, so give yourself a break rather than dickering over it.

A house negotiation is not about winning for the sake of winning. It’s about getting the house you want at a fair price on good terms.

Fail #3: Waiving Formalities Because You’re So in Love With the House

Don’t be so blinded by house love that you do something silly like skip some of the formalities of home buying, such as the  home inspection  or the  appraisal , in an effort to close the deal.

Those steps, and others like a termite or septic inspection, are known as contingencies. They’re there to protect you from ending up with a six-figure money pit.

Imagine how quickly the house-honeymoon would end if you found a termite colony or that the identical house across the street sold for much less?

Besides, if you’re taking out a mortgage, your lender won’t let you skip an appraisal because they don’t want to loan money on a house that isn’t worth the loan amount. So even if you want to make it easy for the seller, your lender may stop you.

There are other ways to sweeten your offer and get that house:

  • Pay some of the seller’s closing costs.
  • Offer a fast close.

If this is your first house, speed is an ace up your sleeve because you can move faster than someone who can’t buy a new house until they sell the old one (another type of contingency).

And remember, while there’s a lot of emotion tied up in choosing a house, it’s still a business deal.

Fail #4: Getting Hung Up On a Few Grand

You offered $198,000. The seller won’t budge from $200,000.

Before you walk away, consider this: Two grand  is  a lot of money, but in the house-buying world it’s not so much. At an interest rate of 4%, with 20% down on a 30-year mortgage, that additional $2,000 will add just $8 a month to your payment.

If you can swing it — maybe you can cut a small thing out of your budget each month — it could be worth it. 

Fail #5: Folding Because the Inspection Turned Up Issues

A good home inspection is going to turn up something. Usually several somethings. That’s good. It means the inspector is doing their job. It’s a rare day when a home passes inspection with no problem at all.

Plus, many things that turn up on an inspection are easily handled. You can ask the seller to do the repairs or knock some off the price so you can pay for repairs.

And while some problems may seem scary at first, like a roof leak or plumbing problem, they’re almost always fixable and negotiable.

Fail #6: Offering Less Because the Decor is Hideous

The faux-Tiffany swag lamp and trippy orange-and-brown wallpaper make your eyes itch. So you’re planning on offering less — way less.

Before you do that, know the market. If it’s a seller’s market, your offer may be seen as an insult especially if the home’s in good shape. And just like that, you’ve lost your dream home.

When you’re ready to make that offer, look past the little stuff that you can easily change, and focus your negotiations on what matters, like the location and the bones of the house.

By Andi Dyer February 1, 2025
Lessons from the Past: Why Waiting for Lower Mortgage Rates Might Not Pay Off
By Andi Dyer January 22, 2025
New funding is coming to support affordable housing for senior citizens in Bellingham. The Washington State Department of Commerce announced nearly $95 million in awards for 27 housing projects around Washington on Thursday, Jan. 16. The Opportunity Council received $5 million for senior housing at a new development near Bellis Fair Mall. The council partnered with the City of Bellingham in June to purchase the 2.7-acre property. The project includes plans for over 120 affordable rental units for low-income families and seniors, with a childcare center that could serve up to 100 kids at a time. Funds from this latest grant will cover 64 units of senior housing—13 of them being offered to homeless residents. Another $4.7 million grant that was announced on Thursday will go towards the Kulshan View affordable housing project in Mount Vernon.  BELLINGHAM, WA (MyBellinghamNow.com) Jason Upton Jason Upton is a reporter and afternoon news anchor at KGMI. Feel free to send any story ideas or news tips to jupton@pnwmediagroup.com. Story © 2025 KGMI - Images © 2025 Saga Communications
By Andi Dyer January 4, 2025
Championing Policies to Strengthen Homeownership and Real Estate Opportunities
By Andi Dyer January 4, 2025
Help Us Grow and Win a Spot in the Anglerfish Sauna!
By Andi Dyer January 4, 2025
Your Personalized Path to Wealth-Building Starts Here 
By Andi Dyer January 4, 2025
Have you ever dreamed of owning your first home but felt stuck, thinking you needed a 20% down payment? Here’s the truth: you don’t need 20%, and there’s help available!
By Andi Dyer January 3, 2025
Strategies To Secure Your Future
By Andi November 2, 2024
These 10 money and time-saving steps can help you craft a winning bid. Ah, the offer! Cinematically speaking, this is the iconic moment — we’d forgive you if you imagined, […] The post STEP 20 – TO BUYING A HOME – MAKE AN OFFER LIKE A BOSS first appeared on Andi Dyer Real Estate.
By Andi October 25, 2024
Dear Friends and Supporters, After many rewarding years with Sterling Real Estate Group, I’ve had the privilege of supporting countless clients and helping many launch their own real estate ventures. […] The post A Life-Changing Decision: I Need to Share This first appeared on Andi Dyer Real Estate.
By Andi October 19, 2024
Real estate negotiation tips so you can buy your dream home — and not overpay. You’ve looked at enough houses to fill an entire season of House Hunters and finally picked one to […] The post STEP 19 – TO BUYING A HOME – 6 WAYS TO LOSE AT NEGOTIATING A HOUSE PRICE first appeared on Andi Dyer Real Estate.
More Posts
Share by: